The following newspaper article was copied from the Record Courier, Ravenna, Ohio, Wednesday, October 28, 1874, Page 3, Column 4:
Man’s Nose Cut
Last week was a bad dry for the Roman nose of Mr. E. J. Shively of Edinburg. Mr. Shively and a party named Green and a butcher named John Wiedamann got “pretty full”, as the street slang is, and were ordered out of Sontum’s saloon, on Main street. Getting into the open air they fell to cuffing each other and finally to fighting, Wiedamann being the under dog in the fight if it was a fight, Wiedamann feeling himself cornered let fly a right-hander, and just at that moment Mr. Shively had as neat a slit cut down the left side of his nose as any Doctor has plastered up of late. Shively procured a warrant from Justice C. A. Reed charging Wiedamann with assault with intent to wound. The case was heard Wednesday, and the testimony all got in during the day, and a nicely “mixed” story it was, as might be expected,, under the circumstances. Shively and Green swore Wiedamann used a knife, and Wiedamann swore he didn’t. But the nose was cut, and Dr. Leonard stated that the injury could have been made only with an instrument having an edge. Thursday forenoon was consumed with arguments of counsel. At the conclusion of which Justice Reed held the accused to bail in the sum of $300, which he gave with Herman Seeman as security. Norton & Phelps for complainant: Shively. W. B. Thomas for def’t Wiedamann.
Elijah J. Shively was born ca. 1849 in Mahoning County, OH and died on 2-Mar-1896 in Alliance, Stark County, OH. He was married to Margaret Lucy Wilson on 4-Jul-1872 in Portage County, OH. Margaret was born on 26-Oct-1848 in Canfield, Mahoning County, OH and died on 13-Feb-1928 in Ravenna, Portage County OH. She was the daughter of Samuel Wilson (1808-1876) and Mary Porter (1817-1886). Elijah J. Shively was the son of Charles Shively (born 3-Jan-1823 in PA, died 6-Mar-1905) and Lucy Ann Noel (born 3-Mar-1825, died 5-Oct-1907). Charles Shively was the son of Lawrence Shively (born 14-Jul-1798 in PA, died 25-Jan-1886 in Mahoning County, OH) and Margaret Best (born 15-Mar-1801 in PA, died 20-Sep-1873 in Mahoning County, OH).
Listed on the 1850 Berlin Township, Mahoning County, OH census is the family of Charles Shively age 27, wife Lucy A. age 25, daughter Sarah A. age 6 and son Elijah age 2. The family is listed on the 1860 Milton Township, Mahoning County, OH census as Charles Shively age 37, wife Lucy A. age 35, daughter Sarah A. age 15, son Elijah age 11, son John age 9, daughter Margaret age 7 and daughter Susan 11 months. On the 1870 Portage County, OH census are Chas Shively age 47, wife Lucy age 45, son Elijah age 22, son John, daughter Margaret age 17 and daughter Susan L. age 11. Found on the 1880 Deerfield, Portage County, OH census are Elija Shively age 31, wife Margaret L. age 31 and daughter Ona May age 4.
Newspaper articles mentioning Elijah (E. J.) Shively follow. Located in the Record Courier, Ravenna, Ohio, October 7, 1868, Page 2, Column 9 is an article which might indicate Elijah was married prior to his marriage to Margaret Lucy Wilson:
SHIVELY-SWEM—AT the house of C. Brown, in Deerfield, Oct 1st, 1868, by Rev. C. Brown, Mr. Elijah Shively and Miss Mary Swem.
The Democratic Press, Ravenna, Ohio, Thursday, September 25, 1873, Page 3, Column 4:
PALMYRA
Special Correspondence of the Press.
FIRE,—Quite a disastrous fire occurred at the Center on Friday last.—The old Palmyra House, on the southeast corner of the Square, which had recently been fitted up by its present proprietor, Mr. John S. Davis, was burned to the ground. The lower part of the main building was occupied by E. J. Shively, as a dry-goods and variety store, the upper part by Charley Brown as a harness shop, the south wing by John Hiser for a dwelling.
The Democratic Press, Ravenna, Ohio, Thursday, March 31, 1881, Page 3, Column 3:
E. J. Shively, the popular salesman at the Diamond Store, is the next happy man, this time a bouncing boy. The last heard of Shively he was asking, is there no rest for the weary?
Record Courier, Ravenna, Ohio, Wednesday, January 24, 1883, Page 1, Column 4:
E. J. Shively’s new store at the Center is making good progress and will be opened by April 1st. A Masonic Hall will be in the second story of the new building.
The Cleveland Leader, Cleveland, Ohio, Friday, June 26, 1885, Page 3, Column 5:
Youngstown
A Merchant Robbed
Special Dispatch to the Leader
YOUNGSTOWN, June 25.— E. J. Shively, a merchant engaged in business at Newport, O., came here yesterday to attend to some legal matters. At an early hour this morning he notified Office Moyer that he had met two colored men, who decoyed him to a stable, under the pretense of looking at a team. When the door closed they knocked him down and rifled his pockets, taking $14, a watch, and a ring. Two men answering the description of the thieves were seen boarding a western train, and it is supposed they have gone to Cleveland.
Record Courier, Ravenna, Ohio, Wednesday, May 12, 1886, Page 1, Column 3:
E. J. Shively was exercising or training a colt, on Tuesday last, and having the line wrapped round his wrist with the buckle on the underside of the strap, the colt gave a sudden spring and the line was tightened so quickly that E. J. had his wrist broken.
The Daily Republican, Raveena, Ohio, Tuesday, October 26, 1886, Page 3, Column 2:A A Palmyra Brute
Assaults His Wife, Cutting Her With A Knife
PALMYRA, O., Oct. 25.—Friday morning last E. J. Shively, of this place, having turned his wife and children out of the house, on her attempting to return gave her a cut across the face with a knife he had in his hand. It is needless to say that the chief cause of the cutting was bad whiskey imbibed the night before. And this occurred in a civilized (?) community and not note is taken of it but a passing remark.
Record Courier, Ravenna, Ohio, Wednesday, November 27, 1889, Page 5, Column 2:
E. J. Shively was arrested Saturday for intoxication. Monday the mayor fined him $5 and costs.
Record Courier, Ravenna, Ohio, Wednesday, June 18, 1890, Page 8, Column 3:
E. J. Shively is our mail carrier now from the Diamond to Ravenna and return.
Record Courier, Ravenna, Ohio, Wednesday, December 17, 1890, Page 1, Column 4:
PALMYRA
We neglected to state last week that we had a new clothing store in town, kept by E. J. Shively in the room formerly used as drug store and post office by E. M. Evans.
The Salem Daily News, Salem, Ohio, Friday, March 6, 1896, Page 4, Column 2:
Adjudged Insane
Elijah Shively, who has played quite an important figure in Alliance police court and in suits against that city, has been adjudged insane at Deerfield and was taken to Alliance today where he was met by Judge Wise of Canton who conducted him to the Toledo insane asylum.
Record Courier, Ravenna, Ohio, Thursday, March 26, 1896, Page 8, Column 2:
The funeral of E. J. Shively took place from the M. E. Church, on Monday. The remains will be buried in the cemetery north of Berlin Center.
The following newspaper obituary for Margaret Lucy Wilson Shively, wife of E. J. Shively, was copied from the Record Courier, Ravenna, Ohio, Tuesday, February 14, 1928, Page 1, Column 3:
C. W. Shively’s Mother Dies
Funeral Rites To Be Held At Her Home Thursday
Mrs. Margaret Shively, widow of Elijah Shively, died at her apartment in Riddle Block 4, Monday at 6:45 o’clock, following an immediate illness of about one week.
Funeral services will be held at the home at one o’clock, Thursday, at which her pastor, Dr. George W. Orcutt, pastor of the First Methodist church, will officiate. Burial is to be in Maple Grove.
Mrs. Shively was born at Canfield, Oct. 26, 1848, and was a resident of Ravenna for a period of thirty-two years. She came here from Alliance.
She is survived by her son, C. W. Shively of this city. A daughter, Mrs. Ona Newmyer, died ten years ago and a son died in infancy.
She was one of ten children of whom Mrs. Rachel Wireman, Akron, is the one survivor.
The following was copied from the Record Courier, Ravenna, Ohio, Friday, February 17, 1928, Page 1, Column 5:
Mrs. Margaret Shively Buried In Maple Grove
Funeral services for Mrs. Margaret Shively, whose death occurred Monday, were held at her home, Riddle Block 4, Thursday afternoon at 1 o’clock, conducted by Rev. G. W. Orcutt, pastor of the M. E. church. Interment was in Maple Grove.
Those from out of town who attended the funeral were Mrs. Rachael Weirman, Mrs. Grover Hoffert, Akron; Mr. and Mrs. Henry Wilson, Mr. and Mrs. Charles Wilson, Vernon Wilson, Berlin Center; Jeff Wilson and daughter, Mr. and Mrs. Jesse Stallsmith, Elsworth; Dudley Wilson, Girard; Mrs. Alice Zellars, Youngstown; Mr. and Mrs. Dallas Wireman, New Milford; Mr. and Mrs. Henry Kline, Mantua; Mr. and Mrs. Rollie Phile, Warren; Willis Canfield, Mrs. Margaret Canfield, Mrs. Clarence Mather, Mrs. Clate Shneiberger, Alliance; Mr. and Mrs. Orrin Shively, Windham; Mr. and Mrs. Warren Knotman and Mrs. Freemont Middleton, Atwater.



