George W. Shively And Mary A. Mowery From Trumbull County, Ohio To Pettis County, Missouri

George W. Shively was born ca. 1836 in Trumbull County, OH and died 26-May-1889 in Pettis County, MO.  He was the son of John Peter Shively and Hannah Flick.  George was married to Mary A. Mowery in Trumbull County, OH in 1857.  Mary was born ca. 1837 and died in 1910.  Both are buried in the Crown Hill Cemetery in Sedalia, Pettis County, MO.

Listed on the 1850 Lordstown District No. 164, Trumbull County, OH census is the family of Peter Shively age 40, wife Hannah age 42, daughter Elizabeth age 20, daughter Mary A. age 18, son George age 17, daughter Margaret age 14, daughter Susannah age 12, son Andrew age 8, son John age 6 and daughter Nancy age 2.  Located on the 1860 Lordstown Township, Trumbull County, OH census are Geo. Shively age 26, wife Mary age 25, daughter Eta age 2 and daughter Olla age 2 months. Listed on the 1870 Heaths Creek Township, Pettis County, MO census is George Shively age 36, wife Mary age 34, daughter Etty age 12, daughter Ollie age 10, daughter Alison age 8, daughter Kitty age 6 and daughter Neely age 4. On the 1880 City of Sedalia, Pettis County, MO is the family of George W. Shively age 46, wife Mary age 44, daughter Etta age 22, daughter Olla age 20, daughter Kittie age 16 and daughter Nelley age 14.

Extracted from the Cleveland Herald, Cleveland, Ohio, Wednesday, April 1, 1857, Page 3,  Column 3:

In Vienna, on the 18 ult, Geo. Shively, to Miss Mary Mowery.

Located in The Sedalia Weekly Bazoo, Sedalia, Missouri, Tuesday, June 4, 1889, Page 3, Column 6:

May 26, at 11 a.m. at his late residence, East Third street, George Shively, aged 54 years. The deceased was a native of Lordstown, Ohio and resided in Sedalia many years.

The funeral will take place at 2:30 o'clock p.m. Tuesday May 29, from the Ohio Street Methodist church.

George W. Shively and Mary A. Mowery were the parents of at least the following children: 1) Etta Jane Shively born 9-Jan-1857 in OH, died 1-Aug-1918 in Pettis County, MO, married Thomas Garrett 2) Olive Belle Shively born 17-Nov-1860 in Ohio, died 20-Oct-1927 in Pettis County, MO, married 3-Nov-1898 in Pettis County, MO to Samuel C. Fuller  3) Alison Shively 1862-1872  4) Kitty Shively born 20-Dec-1865 in Lordstown, Trumbull County, OH, died 8-Feb-1920 in Pettis County, MO, married 11-Jun-1885 in Pettis County, MO to Mahlon D. Smith  5) Neal Shively born 12-Jun-1868 in Ohio, died 30-Aug-1955 in Oklahoma, married to John Henderson Byrum.

Charles Franklin Shively From Union County, PA To Stephenson County, IL To Arapahoe County, CO

Charles Franklin Shively was born on 25-Aug-1842 in Union County, PA and died 7-Feb-1901 in Yuma County, CO. He was the son of Jacob Shively (born ca. 1810) and Sarah (born ca. 1813). Jacob and Sarah are listed on the 1860 Lewis Township, Union County, PA census with sons Charles age 17 and William age 8.  Listed on the 1870 Buck Eye Township, Stephenson County, IL are Jacob Shively age 62 with profession of Cooper, wife Sarah age 57 and son Charles age 26.

Charles Franklin Shively was married to Susan A. Wales in Cadis, Green County, WI on 1-Sep-1877.  Susan was the daughter of Henry and Lovina Wales.  Listed on the 1880 Winslow Township, Stephenson County, IL census is the family of Charles F. Shively age 37, wife Susan A. age 21, son Oliver F. age 2 and William H. age 8 months.  Listed on the 1900 Glendale Precinct No. 7 Eastern District, Arapahoe County, CO census is the household of Charles F. Shively born Aug-1845 age 54, married 24 years, wife Susan born Apr-1857, age 43, having borne 4 children with 4 children living, and son Clyde born Sep-1884 age 15.  

From the Wray Weekly Times, Volume 3 Number 35, February 16, 1901, Page 1, Column 1:

Died

Charles Shively was born Aug. 25, 1842 in Hartle township, Union county, Pennsylvania. Died Feb. 7, 1901, aged 58 years 6 months and 7 days. He moved with his parents to Lena, Stephenson county, Ill., in the spring of 1863. He was married to Susan A. Wales at Cadis, Green county, Wis., in the year 1877 and in the spring of 1885 he moved with his family to York, Neb., where he lived for two years, and from there he moved to Vernon, Colo., where he has since resided. He united with the Seventh Day Adventist Church and was baptized in May 1897, remaining a firm believer to the end. He leaves a widow, three sons and one daughter to mourn his departure. He was buried in the Glendale cemetery last Sabbath, (Saturday) Elder Mackintosh conducting the funeral services. Many friends paid their last tribute of love and respect to the departed husband, father, neighbor, friend and citizen.

[Lines written by a son.]

"The flowers that bloom in spring time shall wither in the fall;

Be ready for the parting. It must come to one and all.

If you are only ready, you will have no fear of death,

And with your Heavenly Father you shall find eternal rest.

The roses bloom but briefly; man's life is here the same,

And when we're called from off the earth, tears should not fall like rain 

For God shall call us soon to leave from this earthly home we've made,

And in the tomb that's made for us our bodies shall be laid."

George Washington Shively And Laura Jane Struble Who Lived In Trumbull County, Ohio

George Washington Shively Marriage

George Washington Shively descends from the Peter Scheibly/Shively line (born 10-Apr-1742 in Switzerland, died 1823 in Perry County, Pennsylvania). George was born on 28-Aug-1841 in Trumbull County, OH and died 10-Mar-1928 in Trumbull County, OH.  George married Laura Jane Struble in Trumbull County, OH on the 16-Feb-1877. Laura Jane was born 27-Jul-1845 and died 11-Jan-1929 in Trumbull County, OH. George Washington Shively, Jr was the son of George Washington Shively, Sr (1798-1883) and Mary Grove Shively (1806-1859).

Located on the 1900 Lordstown Township, Trumbull County, OH census are George Shively born Aug-1841 age 58, wife Jane born Jul-1845 age 54, and son George F. born Aug-1890 age 9.  On the 1910 Lordstown Township, Trumbull County, OH census is the family of George W. Shively age 67, wife Laura J. age 64 and son Floyd G. age 19.  Listed on the 1920 Warren Township Precinct D, Trumbull County census is the household of George Shively age 79, wife Laura age 74, roomer Frank Johns age 39, wife Jennie age 36, and daughter Martha Jane age 9.

The librarians at the Warren-Trumbull County Public Library are given much appreciation for their excellent service in locating the newspaper obituaries for George Washington Shively and Laura Jane Struble Shively as follows:

George W. Shively

A ten days illness with heart trouble and complications terminated in the death this morning at 3:00 o’clock of George Washington Shively, 86 years old, of 212 South Tod av., which occurred in St. Joseph’s RIverside hospital.

Mr. Shively was taken to the hospital February 29, when he was taken suddenly ill at his home, and he failed to rally from the attack that overtook him then. He was born August 28, 1841 in Austintown township, and he spent the greater part of his life in Austintown and Lordstown before taking up his residence in Warren fourteen years ago. He was a farmer by occupation and when he came here he retired from active work. During his active years he was widely known thruout the district as a progressive agriculturist and had many friends. Surviving are his wife, Mrs. Laura J. Shively; a son, George F. Shively; two grand children of Warren, and a sister, Mrs. Caroline Phillips, Youngstown. The remains were taken to the W. J. White Funeral home and will be taken to his home, 212 South Tod Av, Sunday morning.  Funeral services will be held at the home Monday afternoon at two o’clock. The remains will be placed in a crypt in Western Reserve Mausoleum.

Funerals

Services in memory of the late George W. Shively, whose death took place Friday evening, were held Monday afternoon in his home, 212 South Tod avenue. Rev. C. M. Oliphant officiated, and he was assisted by Rev. C. B. Tupper. Beautiful floral tributes covered the casket and the pall bearers were Jesse Beil, J. H. Komray, John Bock, Joseph Wilson, Thomas Webb and William Reeker. The remains were placed in Western Reserve Mausoleum.

Mrs. Laura Jane Shively

Mrs. Laura Jane Shively, 84 died at 4:15 Friday afternoon, at the late home, 212 Tod avenue, S.W., following an illness of eight days with influenza and pneumonia. Mrs. Shively was born July 27, 1844. She had lived in Warren for the past 15 years, coming here from Lordstown.  She was the wife of the late George W. Shively, who died almost a year ago. Surviving are one son, George, Warren and two grandchildren. The body was removed to W. J. White funeral home and will be taken to the late residence Sunday, where funeral services will be held at 1 o’clock Monday afternoon. Entombment will be made in Western Reserve mausoleum.

Also extracted from the newspapers:  Funeral services in memory of Mrs. Laura Jane Shively, who died Friday afternoon, were held at 1 o'clock Monday afternoon at the late home, 212 Tod ave., S.W.   Rev. C. M. Oliphant, officiated.  The pallbearers were Dana Struble, Glen Thompson, George Thomas, Walton Shively, George Buchwalter and Clifford Cassidy.   Entombment was made in Western Reserve mausoleum.

James Shively And Mary C. Meadows Who Lived In Franklin County, Virginia

James Shively was born about 1850 and died on 6-Mar-1873 in Franklin County, VA. He was the son of Jacob Shively and Elizabeth Huff. Jacob Shively and Elizabeth Huff were married in Franklin County, VA on 20-Feb-1847. 

James Shively married Mary C. Meadows in Floyd County, VA on 22-Apr-1872. They had one daughter, Nellie L. Shively who was born 27-Jan-1873 and died 30-Dec-1918.  Nellie Shively married John Sigmon in Franklin County, VA on 30-Dec-1897.  John Sigmon was born ca. 1871 and died on 3-Jan-1946 in Caswell County, NC.

Listed on the 1860 S. Wst. District, Franklin County, VA census is the family of Jacob Shiveley age 31, wife Elizabeth age 31, daughter Mary age 12, son James age 8, daughter Julia age 7, son John E. age 4 and daughter Virginia age 1.  Located on the 1870 Long Branch Township, Franklin County, VA census is Jacob Shively, age 48, wife Malinda age 44, son James age 20, daughter Julia age 17, son Edward age 15, daughter Virginia age 12, daughter Eliza age 9, son Sparrel age 7 and daughter Elizabeth age 4.

The following article was found in the Richmond Dispatch, Richmond, Virginia, Wednesday, March 12, 1873, Page 3, Column 2:

A little affray took place at Rocky Mount on Monday evening about dark, which resulted in a very serious if not fatal injury of one of the parties engaged. A very pestilent fellow named Hodges struck a young man by the name of Shively on the head with a four-pound weight. Shively has been delirious nearly ever since and now lies in an unconscious state. His physicians think it hardly probable that he can recover. Hodges has been arrested and lodged in jail. Public sentiment is very strong against Hodges, and he will doubtless be punished to the utmost that the law will allow.

Extracted from The Norfolk Virginia, Norfolk, Virginia, Tuesday, August 12, 1873, Page 1, Column 6:

The trial of Jacob S. Hodges, for the killing of James J. Shively, in Franklin county, is progressing before the Circuit Court in Roanoke county. This case was removed from the county of Franklin where the killing took place.

The following was located in The Norfolk Virginian, Norfolk, Virginia, Friday, August 22, 1873, Page 1, Column 6:

Jacob S. Hodges was convicted in Roanoke county, last week, of killing young Shively, at Franklin Courthouse, last March, and sentenced to fifteen years in the penitentiary.

Phillip Leroy Shively, Great Grandson of Jacob Shively And Isabel Reed Who Lived In Howard And Chariton Counties, Missouri

Phillip Leroy Shively was born on 30-Oct-1928 in Kansas City, KS and died on 5-Apr-2000 in Rancho Mirage, Riverside County, CA.  He was the son of Phillip Thurman Shively (born 3-Nov-1903 and died 2-Dec-1977) and Paralee Bowen (born 13-Aug-1905 and died 4-Dec-1998). Phillip Thurman Shively was the son of William Sigmund Shively (born Mar-1861 in Ohio and died 12-Feb-1933 in Howard County, MO) and Virginia "Jennie" F. Bentley , Kan. (born 16-Apr-1867 in Chariton County, MO and died 16-Aug-1946 in Jackson County, MO).  William Sigmund Shively was the son of Jacob Shively (born 1-Nov-1827 in Jefferson County, OH and died 13-Oct-1897 in Chariton County, MO) and Isabel Reed (born 21-Jun-1830 in Jefferson County, OH and died 17-Jun-1911 in Chariton County, MO). (For more information on Jacob Shively see the Shively blog article written on December 9, 2016). Jacob Shively was the son of Richard Shively (1808-1887) and Mary Calvert who were in Jefferson County, Ohio.

Phillip Leroy Shively was born on 30-Oct-1928 in Kansas City, KS and died on 5-Apr-2000 in Rancho Mirage, Riverside County, CA. A marriage record was found in the Jackson County, MO marriages for Phillip Leroy Shively and Shirley Moore who were married on 26-May-1950. Phillip was married at least a second time to Irene R. Illes on 10-Dec-1964 in Las Vegas, NV.  The following was found in The Desert Sun, Palm Springs, California, Friday, April 7, 2000, Page 24, Column 6:

Phillip Shively, 71

Phillip L. Shively, 71, a 26-year resident of Desert Hot Springs, died on April 5, 2000, in Rancho Mirage.

He was born on Oct. 30, 1928 to Phillip T. and Paralee B. Shively at Kansas City, Kan. He married Irene R. Illes on Dec. 10, 1964, in Las Vegas.

Mr. Shively was a self-employed real estate manager in Los Angeles for 15 years and an artist/sculptor in Desert Hot Springs for 25 years.

He served in the Navy in 1944 and 1945.

Mr. Shively is survived by his wife, Irene of Desert Hot Springs and his daughter, Nancy Dow of Palm Desert.

Services will be private.

Interment will be in Hollywood Forever Cemetery, Los Angeles with Rose Mortuary of Desert Hot Springs in charge of arrangements.

Phillip Thurman Shively was born 3-Nov-1903 and died 2-Dec-1977 in a hospital in Columbia, Boone County, MO and Paralee Bowen born 13-Aug-1905 and died 4-Dec-1998. The following was extracted from The Sedalia Democrat, Sedalia, Missouri, Sunday, December 4, 1977, Page 4, Column 1:

Phillip T. Shively

GRAVOIS MILLS --Phillip Thurman Shively, 74, died Friday at the Ellis-Fischel Hospital in Columbia.

He was born Nov. 3, 1903, in Glasgow, son of the late Sigmund and Virginia Bentley Shively. On Feb. 22, 1922, he married Miss Paralee Bowen, who survives of the home here.

He was retired stationary fireman for the Corn Products Co. of North Kansas City.

Surviving is a son, Phillip LeRoy Shively, Desert Hot Springs, Calif.

Funeral services will be held at 11 a.m. Monday at the Kidwell-Garber Funeral Home, Versailles, with the Rev. Carlton Cassidy officiating.

Burial will be in the Versailles Cemetery.

Friends may call after 12 noon Sunday at the funeral home.

William Sigmund Shively was born born Mar-1861 in Ohio and died 12-Feb-1933 in Howard County, MO) and Virginia "Jennie" F. Bentley born 16-Apr-1867 in Chariton County, MO and died 16-Aug-1946 in Jackson County, MO.  They were married in Chariton County, MO on 24-Dec-1886.

Jacob Shively was born 1-Nov-1827 in Jefferson County, OH and died 13-Oct-1897 in Chariton County, MO and Isabel Reed was born 21-Jun-1830 in Jefferson County, OH and died 17-Jun-1911 in Chariton County, MO.  The following was located in the Chariton Courier, Keytesville, Missouri, June 23, 1911, Page 1, Column 6:

Obituary

Mrs. Isabelle Shively, born June 21, 1830, died at the home of her son, George Shively June 17, 1911. She was a native of Ohio, and her maiden name was Isabelle Reid. Married to Jacob Shively at Jefferson County Ohio, December 23, 1852 coming to Missouri in May 1867 and living in Howard county until 1880, moving to Chariton county in that year. Her husband Jacob Shively died in 1898 and since that time she lived with her son Lou until his death two years ago, after which she made her home with her other children. Grandma Shively died a member of the Helna church, Methodist, tho in early life was converted and became a member of the Campbellite church at her girlhood home. She was the mother of six boys and six girls, eight of whom survive her. Her remains were laid to final rest in the cemetery at Glasgow, funeral services having been conducted at the residence of her son George Shively by Rev. J. A. Snarr.

William Grover Shivley, Son Of William H. Shivley, Who Lived In Allegany County, Maryland

William Grover Shivley was born on 3-Feb-1889 Lockseven, West Virginia and died 2-Aug-1957 in Allegany County, MD.   He was the son of William H. Shivley and Elizabeth Jennie Pring. Willliam Grover Shivley married 1st Edith F. Nunemaker who passed away on 27-Apr-1947 in Baltimore, MD.  He married 2nd Melvina M. Blacklin who had first married Maurice A. Cubbage who died in 1944 in World War II.  Melvina was born 8-Jan-1921 and died 26-Dec-1995 in Cumberland, Allegany County, MD.  

The following was found in The Cumberland News, Cumberland, Maryland, Saturday, August 3, 1957, Page 2, Column 5:

William G. Shivley

William Grover Shivley, 68, husband of Melvina (Blacklin) Shivley, 129 Arch Street, died yesterday in Newton D. Baker VA Center, Martinsburg, W. Va. He had been in ill health for serval weeks. 

He was born at Lock Seven, W. Va. and was retired from the U. S. Army with 30 years of service.

He was a member of Henry Hart Post 1411; Monumental Lodge 96, AF&AM; Forest 45, Tall Cedars of Lebanon, Baltimore; the IOOF of Baltimore; Rebeccas of Baltimore, and a member of the National Association of Civil Employes.

The body is at the Scarpelli Funeral Home, where services will be conducted Monday at 4 p.m. Rev. T. Wilbur Lawton, pastor of Southminster Presbyterian Church, will officiate and interment will be in Hillcrest Burial Park.

The following was located in The Gazette and Daily, York, Pennsylvania, Monday, April 28, 1947, Page 26, Page 3:

Mrs. William Shivley

Edith F. Nunemaker Shivley, wife of William Shivley, 816 St. Paul street, Baltimore, died yesterday morning at 12:40 o'clock in University hospital, Baltimore, where she was a surgical patient. She was 52.

Surviving besides her husband are three brothers and a sister, Ralph E. Nunemaker, 267 South Belvidere avenue; Paul Nunemaker, 332 North Newberry street, Mrs. William Knokey, 285 Cottage Hill road, and Chester Nunemaker, 818 North Duke street.

She was a member and past president of Ladies' auxiliary No. 3, Patriarch Militant, IOOF; Lt. George B. Redwood auxiliary No . 193, Veterans of Foreign Wars; Ladies of the Orient M.D. of P. Aden Zuanna No. 80, LOTO; Ladies' auxiliary, Military Order of the Purple Heart, Unit No. 122, and also Maryland state chaplain of this group; Martha Washington Rebekah lodge No. 8, IOOF, in which she was past noble grand. She received a decoration of chivalry from the last mentioned organization. All of these associations are in Baltimore. In addition she was a member of Mammy Ruggles Tent No. 50, Daughters of Union Veterans of the Civil War, York.

Funeral services will be conducted Wednesday at 2 p.m. (DST) from the family residence, 818 North Duke street. Rev. Dr. Carl N. Mundis, pastor of Fifth EUB church, will officiate. Interment will be in Prospect Hill cemetery.

The following was extracted from the Cumberland Times News, Cumberland, MD, Friday, December 29, 1995, Page 18, Column 4:

SHIVLEY FUNERAL

CUMBERLAND -- Services for Melvina M. Shivley, 74 of York, Pa., formerly of Cumberland, will be conducted at the Scarpelli Funeral Home, 108 Virginia Ave., on Friday at 11 a.m. with the Rev. Peter M. Goetscheus officiating. Interment will be in Hillcrest Burial Park.

James Floyd Shively And Anna Elizabeth Fowler Who Lived In Marion County, Kentucky

James Floyd Shively was born Nov-1862 in Phillipsburg, Marion County, KY and died 3-Nov-1936 in Phillipsburg, Marion County, KY. He is buried in the St. Francis de Saales Cemetery in Spurlington, Taylor County, KY. James Floyd Shively was the son of Thomas Robert Shively (born 6-Jun-1833 died 15-Sep-1910 buried St. Francis de Saales Cemetery) and Julia Ann Jarboe (1838-1922).  Thomas Robert Shively was the son of Henry H. Shively and Elizabeth Heaverin.  Henry H. Shively was the son of John Shively and Susannah Hayden.  

James Floyd Shively married Anna Eliza Fowler  on 22-Nov-1887 at St. Francis Catholic Church. This Marriage Bond is recorded in Marion County, KY Marriage Volume 9, Pages 616-617.  According to this information James was 25 years old and Anniliza was 15 years old.  The bond was signed by Jas. F. Shively and Peter Edelen.  

Anna Eliza Fowler was born on 3-Feb-1872 or 1873 and died 16-Jul-1901 in Marion County, KY. She was the daughter of Charles Robert Fowler (1842-1878) and Mary Elizabeth Edelen (1852-unknown).  Anna Eliza is located on the 1880 New Market District, Marion County, KY census in the household of Peter C. Edelen age 40, wife Esther age 28, son Peter C. Jr age 1 and great-niece Annie E. Fowler age 7. 

James Floyd Shively and Anna Eliza Fowler were the parents of the following children: 1) Julia Ann Shively born 25-Jul-1894 in Marion County, KY died 18-Oct-1932 buried in Our Lady of the Hills Cemetery, Taylor County, KY.  She married Elmer Green Hay who was born 3-Sep-1885 died 4-Jan-1961 buried Old Liberty Cemetery, Marion County, KY. Elmer was the son of James and Lizzie Hay.  On the death certificate for Julia Ann Shively Hay she lists her parents as Floyd Shively and Anna Jarboe.  Julia would have been about 7 years old when her mother Anna Fowler died in 1901 and her father Floyd Shively would have still been alive in 1932 so am not sure why her mother is listed as Anna Jarboe. (Note that later Anna Jarboe will be discussed in connection with Julia’s sister who was Anna Elizabeth Shively born in May-1901 which was 2 months before the death of their mother, Anna Fowler Shively).   Elmer Green Hay married after the death of Julia Ann Shively to Rhoda Pearl Milby Bell. From the Central Kentucky News Jornal, January 12, 1961 is the following obituary:  Funeral services were conducted Friday at Bradsfordville Baptist Church for Elmer Green Hay, who died Wednesday, January 4, 1961, at St. Joseph Infirmary, Louisville. He was a retired farmer and employee of the Louisville & Nashville Railroad Company.  Surviving are his wife, Mrs. Pearl Milby Hay; 3 daughters, Mrs. Ruth Hinkle, Iowa; Mrs. Rita Wheat, New York; and Mrs. Margaret Sharp, Louisville; a stepdaughter, Mrs. Edgar Edelen, Bradfordsville; 2 sisters, Mrs. Bunn Armstrong and Mrs. Forrest Maupin, both of Campbellsville; George Hay, Venton, IA; and Diezard Hay, Laporte City, IA.  2) James Robert Shively born on 28-Oct-1895 in Marion County, KY died 16-Feb-1967 Louisville, Jefferson County, KY buried Mount Zion Cemetery, Campbellsville, Taylor County, KY. He was married to Viola Allen in 1944.  From the The News-Journal, February 23, 1967: Funeral services were conducted at the Lyon Funeral Home Chapel Sunday, Feb. 19, at 2:00 p.m. for James Robert "Bob" Shively, who died at the Veterans Hospital in Louisville, Thursday, Feb. 16, at 9:25 p.m. Death was due to a cerebral vascular accident. Services were in charge of Elder Herbert Martin and burial was in the Zion Cemetery at Acton. Mr. Shively, 71, lived on Campbellsville Star Route, in the Saloma Community and formerly lived in the Acton Community. He was born in Marion County, October 28, 1885, son of Mr. and Mrs. James Floyd Shively. In May 1944 he was married to Viola Allen, who survives. Besides his wife, he is survived by one daughter, Mrs. Nora Lee Dickerson, Rt. 6; one step-daughter, Mrs. Dorothy Lawson, Star Route; three step-grandchildren and one sister, Mrs. Annie Hay, Vinton, Iowa. Pallbearers were Leonard and David Lawson, Huston Cox, Franklin Deray, George B. Tungate and Dalton Cox. 3) Lizzie Hester Shively born 1897 4) Anna Elizabeth Shively born 23-May-1901 in Marion County, KY died 24-Nov-1992 in Tampa, Hillsborough County, FL. She was married to George Hamilton Hay (1887-1973). George Hay was a brother to Elmer Hay who married Anna Shively’s sister, Julia Ann Shively. Anna Elizabeth Shively was 2 months old when her mother, Anna Eliza Fowler died in July 1901.  James Floyd Shively must not have wanted to care for a 2 month old baby because Anna Elizabeth Shively was raised in the household of Robert Fowler (1875-1915) and Annie Elizabeth Jarboe (1876-1952). The marriage of Robert C. Fowler and Anna E. Jarboe is recorded in Marion County Marriage Book Volume 12, Pages 178-179. They were married at Calvary on 13-Nov-1894. Annie E. Jarboe was the daughter of James T. Jarboe (1835-1914) and Sarah E. Listed on the 1910 Magisterial District No. 5, Marion County, KY census is the household of Robert C. Fowler age 34, wife Annie L. age 33, adopted mother Allathe Wooley age 68 and niece Annie L. Shively age 9.  Located on the 1920 Monroe Township, Benton County, IA census is the family of George H. Hay age 41, wife Anna age 29, son Robert age 11, daughter Corrine age 10 months and mother-in-law age 51. Locatd on the 1940 Lincoln Township, Blackhawk County, IA census is George Hay age 53, wife Anna age 39, daughter Corrine age 10, daughter Leola age 8 and mother-in-law Anna Fowler age 63.

James Floyd Shively and Anna Eliza Fowler are documented in the following census records: 1900 Marion County, KY census James F. Shively born Nov-1862 age 37, wife Annie E. born Feb-1872 age 27, daughter Julia A born Jul-1893 age 6, son James R. born Oct-1895 age 4, daughter Lizzie H. born Apr-1897 and uncle Peter Jarboe born Oct-1822 age 67; 1910 Magisterial District No. 6, Taylor County, KY Loyd Shively age 47 widowed daughter Juilia age 16, son Robert age 14; 1920 South Lebanon Precinct, Marion County, KY Floyd Shively age 57, sister Julia age 50 and son Robert age 24; 1930 Magisterial District No. 4, Marion County, KY Floyd Shively age 68, son Robert age 35, daughter-in-law Lula age 28 and mother-in-law Nancy Allen age 70.